COMPARE · WHEN I WORK · CONNECTEAM
vs

Inspection timestamps aren't a time clock.

When I Work and Connecteam are good, affordable scheduling and time clock apps. Some operators skip them and use DVIR timestamps instead. Either way, someone still turns times into payable hours by hand. InstaRoute builds the shift, verifies clock-in at the depot, applies break and overtime rules, and exports approved hours, while dispatch sees who's actually available.

Payroll is due Friday

Rebuild the hours, or approve them.

InstaRoute
  1. 1Review flagged shifts and approve
  2. 2Export in your payroll's format
DVIR stamps or a separate clock
  1. 1Export inspection or clock times
  2. 2Work out breaks and overtime in a spreadsheet
  3. 3Check time off in another app
  4. 4Re-key hours into payroll
Row by row, sourced

Where each one runs it.

CapabilityInstaRouteTime clock apps
Weekly shifts, templates, copy forward, publish3IncludedWhen I Work, Connecteam
Clock-in geofencing per depot3On or off per depotGPS clock-in, varies by tier
Punches outside the geofence3Flagged at approvalVaries by app
Break, overtime, attestation rules3Federal and state rulesVaries by plan
Time-off requests and balances3IncludedIncluded
Export approved hours to payroll1Standard or custom formatPayroll integrations
Dispatch sees who's scheduled and on duty3Feeds driver picksSeparate system
Built inAdd-onDifferent modelNot shown publicly
  1. 1When I Work pricingchecked Oct 21, 2026
  2. 2Connecteam pricingchecked Oct 21, 2026
  3. 3InstaRoute Time and Attendancechecked Oct 21, 2026
  4. 4InstaRoute pricingchecked Oct 21, 2026
Credit where it's due

Good at what it's for.

Time clock apps does this well

When I Work and Connecteam make scheduling and time tracking easy for hourly teams across many industries, with mobile apps, shift swapping, and payroll integrations at a low per-user price. Inspection apps record exactly when a vehicle was checked, which is useful compliance evidence.

  • Easy hourly scheduling
  • Low per-user cost
  • Payroll integrations
Where the operating model differs

For a fleet, the shift, the vehicle, the inspection, and the trips are one day of work. InstaRoute applies the hour rules to that day, flags any punch outside the depot geofence for the manager, and tells dispatch who can take the next trip.

  • Hours rules applied, not rebuilt
  • Off-site punches flagged at approval
  • Exported in your payroll's format
What it costs at your size

The bigger number is the hours rebuilt.

InstaRoute Tracked
$1,125$45 × 25 vehicles
  • Dispatch, unlimited trips and users
  • Preconfigured vehicle GPS
  • DVIR and maintenance
  • Time and attendance
  • Radio, Team Chat, Inbox
  • Flight IQ, InstaTrain, branded website
Difference$675/mo
A time clock + the tools beside it
  • When I Work · Pro$5 × 35 users (drivers + office) · annual billing$175
  • Samsara · Vehicle Gateway license$39 × 25 vehicles · annual billing · reported$975
  • Whip Around · Standard (Inspect)$5 × 25 vehicles · annual billing$125
  • Zello Work · Plus$15 × 35 users (drivers + office)$525
Per month$1,800

Honest read: Connecteam Operations Advanced is $59 for 30 users plus $3 each after that, so the cheaper option depends on your team size. The larger cost is the office time spent turning stamps into payroll, which we'll estimate with you on the call.

Build your exact stack in the savings calculator Savings pricing research: Oct 13, 2026. Billing terms are shown per line; reported figures are labeled. Hardware and setup fees are excluded from monthly totals.
Bring this to both demos

Test it on a real day.

  1. 1

    Take one driver's week: compare hours from DVIR stamps with payable hours after break and overtime rules.

  2. 2

    Approve a day off and see whether dispatch stops suggesting that driver.

  3. 3

    Clock out away from the depot, then open the shift as a manager and find the out-of-geofence flag before approving.

Where each one fits

Two tools. Two jobs.

May fit

A standalone time app

may fit teams whose schedules have no connection to vehicles or trips.

May fit

InstaRoute

may fit fleets that want shifts, clock-ins, time off, and dispatch on the same clock.

Before you book the call

Questions operators ask first.

No. InstaRoute exports approved hours in the standard payroll formats, or a custom layout that matches your setup.

Compare the hours your payroll actually pays.

Bring one real workflow. We'll show you how the same day runs in InstaRoute.

Company setup includedHardware arrives preconfiguredLive support through go-live